Does love and family coexist?
Millions of children are raised in
a family with unconditional love, others are raised by people who love them only
halfway, and the rest of the millions don’t receive love from any parent. Jojo and Kayla receive love from their grandparents
and so does Leonie, while Richie receives it from Pop. In this way, does love and family coexist?
I believe there is always love in
the family someone makes for themselves, whether that be by blood or not. For Jojo, he didn’t find love from his mother,
so he seeks out Pop who he respects and wants to make proud. The very first page of the book describes
Jojo’s desperate need for Pop to understand and respect him. After all, Jojo doesn’t even consider Leonie
to be his mother, and Kaya, despite being so young, doesn’t give her this title
either.
When it comes to Richie, he died
protecting his family. Readers can
assume that his mother and father are absent in similar ways that Leonie is
absent from Jojo and Kayla’s life, where there isn’t enough protection and sustenance
being provided. In attempting to provide
for his family at such a young age (as Jojo does for Kayla), he ends up going
to Parchman and never seeing them again.
His arrest rips him away from his old family and his old definition of love,
so he in turn finds his new family and sense of love in River. River saved him from as much torture and pain
as possible to the point where River began to feel “happier than [he] had been
before, still lighter, almost, maybe okay” (page 139). Going against this, how can one say River
was like a father to him when he ultimately was the one who killed Richie? I believe it was almost a God-sent blessing
to Richie because it saved him from the brutal torture he would suffer from the
white mob who was hunting after him, and I believe River thought he was giving
him peace by letting him escape from the hands of someone who loved him. However, River wasn’t fully ethical because Richie
might have been able to run away and give his family a better life and live past
12 years old. Readers see this possible mistake
because it’s not very clear whether this story frees Richie, as he just disappears
rather violently.
Readers also see Leonie's betrayal of her children. Her past
is her past and she got addicted to drugs, and it being her fault or not is another
topic in of itself, but I believe it was her duty as a mother to sober up and
be there for her kids especially when their father couldn’t be. I think Leonie loves her kids in a twisted
way, and we see this when they get pulled over because she gets scared to death
that he will kill her babies, and yet she still berates them and doesn’t give
them anything. Despite Leonie betraying
her kids by not being a present and loving mother, she doesn’t betray her other
family in the end. Right as Mam begins to
get within days of death, we see Leonie break mentally for the first time and comprehend
that her mother won’t be there soon, and I believe Leonie understands that she
needs to begin making right everything she has done wrong. We see this attempt to be better whenever she
gathers stones to lay at her mother's bedside as she passes away, and she does
this to link her mother's soul to nature because that is where she has found
the most peace. Even Richie, who has
been searching for love this entire time, begins to “hear the song again; I
know that singing … I have heard it from the golden place across the waters” (page
245). This song represents the freedom
from life that is emitted by those who have passed along, truly highlighting
how much Leonie cared for her mother in her last moments as she called upon the
spirit who would let her rest peacefully.
Overall,
I think one can find love in any situation one defines as family. Jojo finds love within Pop and Kayla, Leonie
finds love in her parents, just the same as Richie finds love in River. Yet I also believe the ones who love and are
loved by someone can be the ones who ultimately destroy it in the name of love.
I agree with your interpretation of how love is portrayed in the narrative, particularly in the dynamics between specific characters in the novel. Jojo’s relationship with Pop highlights that family extends beyond direct parentage, as Jojo, feeling abandoned by Leonie, leans more towards Pop and Man for guidance and love. This is evident when he thinks about how much he wants to make Pop proud, reflecting how much he looks up to Pop and their bond. Similarly, Richie’s bond with River elucidates love as a sense of home; River’s heartbreaking choice to kill Richie, believing it spares him from a worse fate, raises profound moral questions. In a moment of peace, Richie reflects, “I have heard it from the golden place across the waters” (page 245), signifying his longing for belonging and freedom. As mentioned, Leonie's struggles with addiction further complicate familial love. Throughout the story, we can see how she cares for Jojo and Kayla and wants to improve as a mother but struggles to give them her love, revealing her conflicting emotions of love and fear. In her moment of clarity as her mother nears death, gathering stones to honor her, she realizes she wants to correct her past actions. This act symbolizes her attempt at redemption, suggesting that love evolves, even amidst events in her past that hurt her. Sing, Unburied, Sing demonstrates how love shapes identities and relationships, showing how patterns of treatment can be followed over time or be subject to change within generations.
ReplyDelete